#127248: "Only 4 settlements allowed instead of 5 after a barbican attack followed by city rebuilding"
这个案件是关于哪方面的？
发生什么事? 请从下方选择
发生什么事? 请从下方选择
请检查是否已有同课题案件
若肯定，请「投票」给这桩案件。最高票的案件将「优先」处理！
| # | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
|---|
细节描述
-
• 如果有的话，请将你在屏幕上所看到的错误信息粘贴出来.
In catan cities and knights, a maximum of 5 settlements and 4 cities are allowed. One player whose city was pillaged and reduced to a settlement had rebuilt the settlement to a city, so the cities built increased to 1 but available settlements remained 0 and the player now had only 4 settlements, 1 city but 0 settlements left to build
-
• 请说明你当时想做什么，你做了什么，然后发生了什么
Yes, move 323
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.5
-
• 请以英文复制／粘贴显示文字而非你的语言。 如果你已截取此Bug的屏幕截图（好习惯），可使用任意图片托管服务（例如snipboard.io）上传后，将链接复制粘贴至此处。 这段文本在翻译系统中吗？如果存在，它被翻译是否已超过二十四小时？
In catan cities and knights, a maximum of 5 settlements and 4 cities are allowed. One player whose city was pillaged and reduced to a settlement had rebuilt the settlement to a city, so the cities built increased to 1 but available settlements remained 0 and the player now had only 4 settlements, 1 city but 0 settlements left to build
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.5
-
• 请简明而精确地解释您的建议，以便让人明白您想表达的意思。
In catan cities and knights, a maximum of 5 settlements and 4 cities are allowed. One player whose city was pillaged and reduced to a settlement had rebuilt the settlement to a city, so the cities built increased to 1 but available settlements remained 0 and the player now had only 4 settlements, 1 city but 0 settlements left to build
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.5
-
• 当你被封锁的时候，屏幕上出现了些什么呢？(空白的屏幕？部分游戏平台画面？错误的信息？)
In catan cities and knights, a maximum of 5 settlements and 4 cities are allowed. One player whose city was pillaged and reduced to a settlement had rebuilt the settlement to a city, so the cities built increased to 1 but available settlements remained 0 and the player now had only 4 settlements, 1 city but 0 settlements left to build
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.5
-
• 哪个规则没有被BGA的设计小组写进游戏里？
In catan cities and knights, a maximum of 5 settlements and 4 cities are allowed. One player whose city was pillaged and reduced to a settlement had rebuilt the settlement to a city, so the cities built increased to 1 but available settlements remained 0 and the player now had only 4 settlements, 1 city but 0 settlements left to build
-
• 在游戏回放中，是否有不符合游戏规则的地方？如果有的话，请问是在哪一步呢？
Yes, move 323
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.5
-
• 你当时是想做哪个游戏行动？
In catan cities and knights, a maximum of 5 settlements and 4 cities are allowed. One player whose city was pillaged and reduced to a settlement had rebuilt the settlement to a city, so the cities built increased to 1 but available settlements remained 0 and the player now had only 4 settlements, 1 city but 0 settlements left to build
-
• 你在想做什么的时候，触发了这个游戏选项？
Yes, move 323
-
• 当你想这么做时，发生了什么事(错误信息，游戏状态信息，......)？
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.5
-
• 请问这个问题发生在游戏的哪个阶段(当前的游戏说明是什么)？
In catan cities and knights, a maximum of 5 settlements and 4 cities are allowed. One player whose city was pillaged and reduced to a settlement had rebuilt the settlement to a city, so the cities built increased to 1 but available settlements remained 0 and the player now had only 4 settlements, 1 city but 0 settlements left to build
-
• 当你想进行一个游戏行动时，发生了什么事(错误信息，游戏状态信息，......)？
Yes, move 323
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.5
-
• 请描述一下显示画面上面的问题。 如果你已截取此Bug的屏幕截图（好习惯），可使用任意图片托管服务（例如snipboard.io）上传后，将链接复制粘贴至此处。
In catan cities and knights, a maximum of 5 settlements and 4 cities are allowed. One player whose city was pillaged and reduced to a settlement had rebuilt the settlement to a city, so the cities built increased to 1 but available settlements remained 0 and the player now had only 4 settlements, 1 city but 0 settlements left to build
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.5
-
• 请以英文复制／粘贴显示文字而非你的语言。 如果你已截取此Bug的屏幕截图（好习惯），可使用任意图片托管服务（例如snipboard.io）上传后，将链接复制粘贴至此处。 这段文本在翻译系统中吗？如果存在，它被翻译是否已超过二十四小时？
In catan cities and knights, a maximum of 5 settlements and 4 cities are allowed. One player whose city was pillaged and reduced to a settlement had rebuilt the settlement to a city, so the cities built increased to 1 but available settlements remained 0 and the player now had only 4 settlements, 1 city but 0 settlements left to build
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.5
-
• 请简明而精确地解释您的建议，以便让人明白您想表达的意思。
In catan cities and knights, a maximum of 5 settlements and 4 cities are allowed. One player whose city was pillaged and reduced to a settlement had rebuilt the settlement to a city, so the cities built increased to 1 but available settlements remained 0 and the player now had only 4 settlements, 1 city but 0 settlements left to build
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.5
案件历史
turn 467 for blue
refresh doesnt resolve issue, and it affects game play
i didnt realize i was down to 4 settlements (same circumstances, lost city, build 5 settlements, rebuild city but did not get a settlement back to my supply). It occurred again after i built 2nd city, so am now down to 3 settlements supply
imgur.com/a/zjaMQQR
than i built 5 villages
than a town
i dont get my village back
Table #571451209
Move #358
Microsoft Edge ver129.0.2792.79 (64bit)
Total number of cities was correct for all users. All 3 users in the game could see the same 0 remaining settlements for the affected user, even after an F5 refresh for all of us, and the user couldn't build their 5th settlement, so I'm guessing it's a server-side bug, but maybe triggered by the way the data was sent by the browser.
Table #579608263; current turn #495 issue probably occurred around #475 or before but couldn't go back that far in the history.
F5 did not solve the issue
Frequency Unknown but seems often given the response.
imgur.com/a/XfAXifU
F5 didn't solve the problem
imgur.com/a/Pia8u0z
Earlier i had lost my city due to barbarian attack. Now my total number of settlements is 4 instead of 5.
I got to know that when in the situation in the imgur URL above, i wanted to build a 5th settlement at the brick port: there was no option to do that, the game automatically placed a knight instead of a settlement.
I also just posted it at boardgamearena.com/bug?id=74816
Table #615897609
Move #241
Progression 55%
Please help as its a long turnbased game.
Same problem repeated itself a 2nd time in the same game (650369104). I now have 2 city's and 4 settlement on the field. The game does not give me the possibility to build a 5th settlement.
I noticed the log says:
"Animal Hunter has more then 5 settlements due to a previous barbaric attack" (I translated from German, original English text might sound different)
This log does not make any sense and it shows that something is wrong with the count of the settlements after a barbaric attack, loosing a city and then rebuilding it.
F5 didn't help. No matter at which position I tried to build my 2nd city.
Early in the game i lost my city. Later I rebuilt a city, I guess it was at the same position.
Later I had built all my 5 settlements + 1 city. Then I upgraded a settlement to city, but still had no settlements instead of 1. The log said (in my own, Dutch language):
SvenOver has more than 5 settlements due to a previous pillagement.
Followed by:
SvenOver upgrades a settlement to a city for 2 grain 2 ore.
So in my case, it seems to have to do with my city loss too.
imgur.com/a/XWJ69Zl
ADDITION to the previous message:
Later, move #444, I upgraded 1 of my then 4 settlements to a city, so then I had 3 settlements and 3 cities on the board. Here the number of settlements available DID change, from 0 to 1. So the increase by 1 DID work this time, although it should have been from 1 to 2 instead of from 0 to 1.
imgur.com/a/wih1Pbt (2 images)
F5 did not solve problem.
Problem appeared multiple times.
Lost city early in game. Had five and ONLY five settlements. After buidling city, my settlement was never put back into play. Four on board, none available.
Later, built second city, that settlement never put back into game. So now two cities, three settlements, none in reserve.
imgur.com/a/table-680116735-iG3P0c9
boardgamearena.com/14/catan?table=687879960
and here is a screenshot:
imgur.com/a/Ae07hHM
White should be able to place a fifth settlement, but that is not allowed as the stock is empty. A city was previously razed and then rebuilt.
boardgamearena.com/6/catan?table=697771010
In the move log for 8/10/2025, appears:
LxLumiere has more than 5 settlements on board due to a previous pillage
LxLumiere upgrades a settlement to a city for...
But that was the first city that LxLumiere built. Other players *had* built cities, and the barbarians *had* visited.
Move #316
i lost a citie, i didnt rebuild it ever, just built others. i dont know how to check it, but i believe i did built 5 settlements, but after building my first or second city i couldnt build another settlements, ended up with 4 max settlements.
增加一些新内容到这篇报告
- 其他的游戏桌 ID / 移动 ID
- 按 F5 是否解决了这个问题？
- 问题是否发生了好几次？还是每次都发生？还是时好时坏？
- 如果你已截取此Bug的屏幕截图（好习惯），可使用任意图片托管服务（例如snipboard.io）上传后，将链接复制粘贴至此处。
