#120162: "Abolish Friendly Robber "
这个案件是关于哪方面的？
发生什么事? 请从下方选择
发生什么事? 请从下方选择
请检查是否已有同课题案件
若肯定，请「投票」给这桩案件。最高票的案件将「优先」处理！
| # | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
|---|
细节描述
-
• 如果有的话，请将你在屏幕上所看到的错误信息粘贴出来.
Friendly robber is not an official rule, yet player are being forced to play this way or face retribution from the other players. I recently played a game where is was never specified or asked that friendly robber be used. I used the robber and was solely targeted for the entire game by every other player, who also brought up in chat that I was not following the "friendly robber rule".
-
• 请说明你当时想做什么，你做了什么，然后发生了什么
yes, follow chat and watch robber action by other players.
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.3
-
• 请以英文复制／粘贴显示文字而非你的语言。 如果你已截取此Bug的屏幕截图（好习惯），可使用任意图片托管服务（例如snipboard.io）上传后，将链接复制粘贴至此处。 这段文本在翻译系统中吗？如果存在，它被翻译是否已超过二十四小时？
Friendly robber is not an official rule, yet player are being forced to play this way or face retribution from the other players. I recently played a game where is was never specified or asked that friendly robber be used. I used the robber and was solely targeted for the entire game by every other player, who also brought up in chat that I was not following the "friendly robber rule".
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.3
-
• 请简明而精确地解释您的建议，以便让人明白您想表达的意思。
Friendly robber is not an official rule, yet player are being forced to play this way or face retribution from the other players. I recently played a game where is was never specified or asked that friendly robber be used. I used the robber and was solely targeted for the entire game by every other player, who also brought up in chat that I was not following the "friendly robber rule".
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.3
-
• 当你被封锁的时候，屏幕上出现了些什么呢？(空白的屏幕？部分游戏平台画面？错误的信息？)
Friendly robber is not an official rule, yet player are being forced to play this way or face retribution from the other players. I recently played a game where is was never specified or asked that friendly robber be used. I used the robber and was solely targeted for the entire game by every other player, who also brought up in chat that I was not following the "friendly robber rule".
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.3
-
• 哪个规则没有被BGA的设计小组写进游戏里？
Friendly robber is not an official rule, yet player are being forced to play this way or face retribution from the other players. I recently played a game where is was never specified or asked that friendly robber be used. I used the robber and was solely targeted for the entire game by every other player, who also brought up in chat that I was not following the "friendly robber rule".
-
• 在游戏回放中，是否有不符合游戏规则的地方？如果有的话，请问是在哪一步呢？
yes, follow chat and watch robber action by other players.
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.3
-
• 你当时是想做哪个游戏行动？
Friendly robber is not an official rule, yet player are being forced to play this way or face retribution from the other players. I recently played a game where is was never specified or asked that friendly robber be used. I used the robber and was solely targeted for the entire game by every other player, who also brought up in chat that I was not following the "friendly robber rule".
-
• 你在想做什么的时候，触发了这个游戏选项？
yes, follow chat and watch robber action by other players.
-
• 当你想这么做时，发生了什么事(错误信息，游戏状态信息，......)？
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.3
-
• 请问这个问题发生在游戏的哪个阶段(当前的游戏说明是什么)？
Friendly robber is not an official rule, yet player are being forced to play this way or face retribution from the other players. I recently played a game where is was never specified or asked that friendly robber be used. I used the robber and was solely targeted for the entire game by every other player, who also brought up in chat that I was not following the "friendly robber rule".
-
• 当你想进行一个游戏行动时，发生了什么事(错误信息，游戏状态信息，......)？
yes, follow chat and watch robber action by other players.
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.3
-
• 请描述一下显示画面上面的问题。 如果你已截取此Bug的屏幕截图（好习惯），可使用任意图片托管服务（例如snipboard.io）上传后，将链接复制粘贴至此处。
Friendly robber is not an official rule, yet player are being forced to play this way or face retribution from the other players. I recently played a game where is was never specified or asked that friendly robber be used. I used the robber and was solely targeted for the entire game by every other player, who also brought up in chat that I was not following the "friendly robber rule".
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.3
-
• 请以英文复制／粘贴显示文字而非你的语言。 如果你已截取此Bug的屏幕截图（好习惯），可使用任意图片托管服务（例如snipboard.io）上传后，将链接复制粘贴至此处。 这段文本在翻译系统中吗？如果存在，它被翻译是否已超过二十四小时？
Friendly robber is not an official rule, yet player are being forced to play this way or face retribution from the other players. I recently played a game where is was never specified or asked that friendly robber be used. I used the robber and was solely targeted for the entire game by every other player, who also brought up in chat that I was not following the "friendly robber rule".
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.3
-
• 请简明而精确地解释您的建议，以便让人明白您想表达的意思。
Friendly robber is not an official rule, yet player are being forced to play this way or face retribution from the other players. I recently played a game where is was never specified or asked that friendly robber be used. I used the robber and was solely targeted for the entire game by every other player, who also brought up in chat that I was not following the "friendly robber rule".
• 您正使用哪一款浏览器呢？
Safari v17.3
案件历史
I feel like for what it's worth, it should be noted that Friendly Robber IS an official variant added to the rulebook in an extension game(Traders & Barbarians) that "may be combined in any Catan scenario" according to their website. I copied and pasted it below directly from the rulebook.
Also, from their website:
"The Friendly Robber - Are victory points on face-down cards also taken into account when determining next to which player I may place the friendly robber? No. Only visible victory points are considered."
"The RULE CHANGE:
When a *7* is rolled or a knight card is played, the robber
may not be moved to a terrain hex that is adjacent to a
settlement of a player who only has 2 victory points. If, because of this rule, the robber has no valid terrain hex to
move to, the robber moves to (or remains on) the desert hex
In this case, a resource card may not be taken from any player who only has 2 victory points.
When using this rule, you still lose half of your resource cards
when a "7" is rolled and you have more than 7 resource cards.
WHAT IT IS ABOUT
Who hasn't experienced the frustration of having the robber
moved next to one of your settlements early in the game? Not
only may you lose a resource- the robber blocks crucial
resource production until a *7* is rolled or a knight card is
played. The "Friendly Robber" variant protects you from the
robber until you have more than 2 victory points
Tips for Playing this Variant;
This variant should always be used when playing with family
members, particularly when children are participating in
the game"
I do wish it was possible to have the variant option available to set as a game option so those who want to play with it can, and those who don't want don't have to without the fear of getting targeted.
My take on it currently is that whoever is the "owner" of the table for the online game, should get to set the rule, the same way as I would expect of the owner of a physical game. I set the "house/variant" rules for my games, and I let the owners of the games set them for their games. If we don't agree in person, we pick a different game.
by abusing the rules of the game, he does not get three points so as not to be punished with robber and this is not youthful.
增加一些新内容到这篇报告
- 其他的游戏桌 ID / 移动 ID
- 按 F5 是否解决了这个问题？
- 问题是否发生了好几次？还是每次都发生？还是时好时坏？
- 如果你已截取此Bug的屏幕截图（好习惯），可使用任意图片托管服务（例如snipboard.io）上传后，将链接复制粘贴至此处。
